Dismiss Notice

You must be 18 or over to participate here.
Dismiss this notice to declare that you are 18+.

Anyone below 18 years of age choosing to dishonestly dismiss this message is accepting the consequences of their own actions.
WW2Talk.Com will not approve of, or be held responsible, for your choices.

Question about WWII history books, eng

Discussion in 'Historiography' started by Metro Tango, Jun 29, 2025.

  1. Sheldrake

    Sheldrake All over the place....

    In 1996 I met John Erickson at a conference. He was on the platform with a German expert on the Wehrmacht Klaus? Paul? Fischer for the session on German and Soviet doctrine. A little wizened chap was sitting next to me in the lecture theatre clutching a photo album. At the end of the session - Any Questions? The wizened chap pips up and in good academic form announces himself with his organisation. "Henry Mettleman, 22nd Panzer Division, I was at Stalingrad. Why did the Russians fight so hard? Erickson answered "One reason was that they shot 15,000 of their own side.".

    Ar dinner I had the privilege of sitting next to John Erickson. His doctoral thesis was on Soviet military Doctrine, which he did from unclassified sources. In the 1950s he was invited by Kruschev to study in the Soviet Union, possibly so Kruschev had an expert on doctrine who was not part of the Red Army. Erickson is worth reading because he had met and interviewed many of the senior Red army men. He met Zukhov at his dacha when he was an unperson.
     
    Metro Tango likes this.
  2. Andreas

    Andreas Working on two books

    That can all be true, and I still find his books turgid and unreadable.

    All the best

    Andreas
     
    Metro Tango likes this.
  3. Metro Tango

    Metro Tango Member

    <edit - I seem to have goobered up my original post, so deleted things>
     
  4. Metro Tango

    Metro Tango Member

    I'm finding it fascinating that things we had no idea about at that time are now part of the accepted narrative. I'm not sure if this is one of those examples, but I still remember the story (forgot where I read it) about how the Russians at Stalingrad would send 2 soldiers to the front with one gun and 3 bullets. They figured at least one of them would make it long enough to fire those 3, but why waste more?
     
  5. JimHerriot

    JimHerriot Ready for Anything

    "Whatever very specific variant you have (mildly complex)... :unsure:"

    A kids special Adam, from way back, when shorts were worn every day but Sunday no matter the weather :)

    Reprint Society 1954, post era paper restrictions, and it's stood the test of time pretty well. As a tacker the maps did it for me, and boy could Trotter draw! Quantity and quality but I could at least understand them and they drew my attention much more than the written word back then (but I've learnt my lesson since). No dust jacket. Either paper aeroplaned or added to the papier-mâché steel helmet makings pile as result of damage sustained during the "gi'ssa look" moments. And I blame the older siblings who should have known better :)

    Cheap as chips nowadays, but for me a keeper for sentimental reasons.

    Kind regards, and happy reading, always,

    Jim.

    IMG_20250701_141731_145~2.jpg

    IMG_20250701_141805_674~2.jpg

    IMG_20250701_141837_933~2.jpg

    IMG_20250701_141859_571~2.jpg

    IMG_20250701_141817_585~2.jpg
     
    Harry Ree and Metro Tango like this.
  6. OpanaPointer

    OpanaPointer Pearl Harbor Myth Buster

    Metro Tango likes this.
  7. EKB

    EKB Well-Known Member


    You seem most interested about U.S. supply chain management, so I would email a military academy or war college to ask for the latest student reading list. For overview of the U.S. political economy, there is Arsenal of World War II by Paul Koistinen. I thought it was informative but have no idea how the subject matter experts rate it.
     
    Last edited: Jul 3, 2025
    Metro Tango likes this.
  8. Metro Tango

    Metro Tango Member

    Hi all,
    Just wanted to follow up here on all your excellent suggestions. This is what I've gotten through so far, starting with a general overview, then diving into the Eastern Front:

    Gerhard L. Weinberg
    A World at Arms: A Global History of World War II

    Norman Davies
    No Simple Victory: World War II in Europe, 1939–1945

    Antony Beevor
    The Second World War

    Richard Overy
    Why the Allies Won

    Donald L. Miller & Henry Steele Commager
    The Story of World War II
    _____________________________________
    Eastern Front
    _____________________________________
    Guy Sajer
    The Forgotten Soldier

    Richard Overy
    Russia's War A History of the Soviet Effort 1941-1945

    Sean McMeekin
    Stalin's War: A New History of World War II (in progress)
    _____________________________________
    On deck
    _____________________________________
    David M. Glantz, Jonathan M. House
    When Titans Clashed: How the Red Army Stopped Hitler

    Chester Wilmot
    The Second World War, The Struggle for Europe (Can't skip this one)

    Thank you all for the guidance! Спасибо большое!
     
  9. Harry Ree

    Harry Ree Very Senior Member

    Chester Wilmot. The Struggle for Europe. A superb publication

    I remember him losing his life in 1954 off Italy when the DH Comet he was in as a passenger broke up in mid air. From the technical inquiry aircraft designers learnt a great deal regarding aircraft stresses.

    An early read of mine and have still got the old paperback somewhere.
     
    Metro Tango and JimHerriot like this.

Share This Page