Dismiss Notice

You must be 18 or over to participate here.
Dismiss this notice to declare that you are 18+.

Anyone below 18 years of age choosing to dishonestly dismiss this message is accepting the consequences of their own actions.
WW2Talk.Com will not approve of, or be held responsible, for your choices.

EC/130 2Lt Arthur Melville PLAYFAIR, 12th Frontier Force Regiment: 15/04/1941 Camerons Ridge Eritrea

Discussion in 'Indian Army' started by Rorerickdew, Feb 25, 2024.

  1. Rorerickdew

    Rorerickdew Member

    2Lt Arthur Melville Playfair fell on 15/04/1941. Can anyone help in information of this young man for a Remembrance Book


    https://www.cwgc.org/find-records/find-war-dead/casualty-details/2272560/arthur-melville-playfair/
    SECOND LIEUTENANT ARTHUR MELVILLE PLAYFAIR
    Service Number: EC/ 130
    Regiment & Unit: 3rd Royal Bn., 12th Frontier Force Regiment
    Date of Death: 15 April 1941
    Age 35 years old
    Buried or commemorated at KEREN WAR CEMETERY
    Grave Reference: 1. A. 6.
    Location: Eritrea
    Additional Info: Son of Arthur Lambert Playfair, C.I.E., and of Mabel Helen Playfair, of Westminster, London.
    Personal Inscription: ONE WHO NEVER TURNED HIS BACK BUT MARCHED BREAST FORWARD-
     
  2. davidbfpo

    davidbfpo Patron Patron

    I started to research and the text is in chronological order, except late on I discovered Playfair was not linked to The Cameron's and possibly not the battle for Cameron's Ridge.

    What information do you have for him being on Cameron's Ridge? I am puzzled.

    You need to view 'The First Victory: The Second World War and the East Africa Campaign' by Andrew Stewart, pub. 2016, as it has for Cameron Ridge pgs. 162, 168-171, 172 and 176. See: The East African Campaign where I have added a review.

    In outline it was an Italian defensive position at Keren, 5k feet hight, which needed to be taken before the main attack on eleven peaks. There were x15 Indian battalions, x3 English and x2 Scottish. It was named after the 2nd Camerons; who took it with the 2/5th Mahratta Light Infantry and together they held it for six weeks - 11th Indian Infantry Brigade being their formation, led by Brigadier Sir Reginald Arthur Savory, part of the 4th Indian Division. It was very hard, long fight, in blistering heat against good Italian and Eritrean opponents.

    A little mention in Post 2: Remembering Today 25/3/41Lance Naik Abbas Ali 14878 6th Rajputana Rifles 1st Bn.

    Using "keren" site:ww2talk.com found many threads, on a quick review other places appear e.g. in Burma. Plus, a ship!

    There appears to be a main thread on Keren: Battle of Keren: toughest of them all? and another from an Italian member on the wider aspects: Mussolini's War series

    There is a very slim Wiki for the 2nd Camerons: Queen's Own Cameron Highlanders - Wikipedia

    Using 2 queen's own cameron highlanders | WW2Talk reveals a number of threads, most I suspect do not refer to Eritrea!

    See Post 5 for a brief history: 2928145 Sgt. George PIERCY 2nd batt. Cameron Highlanders

    This post appears to be the first post on your subject.

    Just checked him and the CWGC entry: https://www.cwgc.org/find-records/find-war-dead/casualty-details/2272560/arthur-melville-playfair/ Shows he was not with the 2nd Camerons, I should have checked earlier! He is shown with 12th Frontier Force Regiment, 3rd Royal Bn. It is possible his Indian Army personal record is on microfiche with The British Library, however a late 2023 cyber attack has made any online research for them hard! I've not checked for a month now.

    A thin Wiki entry:
    From: 12th Frontier Force Regiment - Wikipedia and a mention when searched with FFR: Battle of Keren - Wikipedia

    It appears 3/12th FFR were part of the 9th Brigade at the time. Stewart's book has no individual Index entry for them. There is an indication that four battalions remained in Eritrea after the Italian surrender.

    Hopefully dryan67 will be along as his knowledge of the Indian Army always helps.

    The battle for Keren ended 27/3/1941 and the advance through Eritrea to Asmara and Massawa followed. Playfair could have died from injuries at Keren or afterwards. It appears the Italians surrendered on 8/4/1941, a week later Playfair died.
     
    Last edited: Feb 26, 2024
    Rothy likes this.
  3. Rorerickdew

    Rorerickdew Member

    Thank you for your help. I spent Sunday looking and eventually found he was born in Lancaster gate, Christ Church on 20/08/1905. I believe he was then taken with his parents to Assam - his sister married there. I have written to Dibarugh University to ask for any direction. Playfair died under Italian fire at Karen and is buried in their CWGC Cemetery there. Great fun this!!
     
  4. davidbfpo

    davidbfpo Patron Patron

    Roderick,

    Normally we recommend applying for his Service Record, but he served in an Indian Army unit.

    I will PM dryan67 to ask him to add what he can. He may have the 12th FFR official history (from memory it is a rare book).
     
    Last edited: Feb 26, 2024
  5. Rothy

    Rothy Well-Known Member

    2nd Lieutenant Arthur Melville Playfair

    In 1926, travelled to India, to Calcutta, on board the Mantola. Occupation given as accountant. Last U.K. address given as 49 Carlisle Mansions, SW 1.

    Travelled to Bombay from London on board the Mantua, departed 2nd December 1932. Travelled to Bombay from London on board the Comorin, departed 23rd October 1936; last U.K. address given as 117-118 Leadenhall St, EC2.

    Indian Army Emergency Commission as 2nd Lieutenant, 21st June 1940. Attached to the 12th Frontier Force Regiment from 25th June 1940.

    Steve
     
    davidbfpo likes this.
  6. dryan67

    dryan67 Senior Member

    According to the Roll of Honour (see attached), Second-Lieutenant A.M. Playfair, 3rd Battalion, died of disease on April 15th, 1941 in the Sudan.
    Screenshot 2024-02-26 at 9.13.00 AM.png
     
    davidbfpo and Rothy like this.
  7. dryan67

    dryan67 Senior Member

    Here is my summary history of the 3/12th Frontier Force Rifles for the period March 13th to April 24th, 1941. On April 15th, 1941, the Battalion was under the 9th Indian Brigade doing station duties (garrisoning) in Asmara. It is unclear if his death by disease was related to any of the previous operations.

    HQ 9th Indian Infantry Brigade 13/3/41 - 24/4/41
    After a seven-day journey, the Battalion arrived at Kilo 113 in the Keren bivouac area on the evening of March 13th, 1941 to rejoin the brigade. The second battle of Keren was scheduled to begin on March 15th, 1941 and the 9th Brigade was to take the heights of Fort Dologorodoc, Falestoh, and Zeban. Besides its three battalions, the 9th Brigade would also have the 2nd Highland Light Infantry from 10th Indian Brigade under command. The plan was for the 2nd Highland Light Infantry (from 10th Indian Brigade) to take Fort Dologorodoc after Sanchil was captured. The 9th Brigade would then pass through to take Falestoh, Zeban and Points 1501 and 1560. The attack began on March 15th following a massive but not entirely effective bombardment. Although Sanchil was not taken, the Highland Light Infantry put in their attack on Dologorodoc anyways, but heavy fire from Sanchil prevented its capture. Since the 3/5th Mahrattas had taken the Pinnacle feature by 2000 hours, the 3/12th Frontier Force Regiment passed through and captured the Pimple feature during the early hours of March 16th even though the Battalion only had five platoons from ‘B’ and ‘C’ Companies in the operation (‘A’ was on Gondar road, ‘D’ and a platoon of ‘B’ were portering). Both battalions fought off counterattacks during the morning allowing the 2nd West Yorkshire Regiment to pass through and pursue the Italians. The 2nd West Yorks took Fort Dologorodoc at 0615 hours on March 16th. The Italians put in a number of counterattacks against the Fort during the day. During the 17th, the 9th Brigade consolidated its position in the Fort area. Between March 18th and 22nd, the Italians put in seven attacks against the Fort area. On March 19th, the forces on Mount Dologorodoc were reorganized and the 3/12th Frontier Force Regiment (less one company) relieved the 3/2nd Punjab Regiment on the features north of the fort with a company of the 6/13th Frontier Force Rifles passing to the command of the 3rd Battalion. For the next eight days, the Battalion remained in these positions, which were overlooked by Sanchil and Falestoh. On the night of the 22nd, the 3rd Sikhs were attacked by an enemy battalion but held firm.

    In the final assault on Keren, the 9th Indian Brigade would capture Hillock ‘A’ by 0430 hours on March 25th in the first phase of the operation, take Hillock ‘B’ in the second phase, and in the third phase the captured ground was to be consolidated with the 9th Brigade prepared to secure the ridge west of the Railway Bridge. The fourth phase would involve the 29th Indian Infantry Brigade only. The 3/12th Frontier Force Regiment reported Italian artillery firing on Hillock ‘A’ at 1745 hours on March 24th allowing the 2nd West Yorks to take the feature at 2330 hours. The next morning the 3/5th Mahratta Light Infantry took Hillock ‘B’ against stiff opposition. A final counterattack was repulsed during the morning of March 26th and the Battalion spent the next morning salvaging enemy equipment and moved to some wells on the main Keren road during the afternoon. The following morning, the Battalion was bivouacked just outside Keren town. It moved up to the front again at 0500 hours on March 30th.

    On March 30th, the 10th Indian Brigade had advanced forward of Keren to MS 64 and the 9th Brigade had moved up to MS 71. The 9th Brigade was ordered to attack the ridge on the road at MR 726694 at 1630 hours, but the attack was postponed until the following morning. At 0445 hours on March 31st, the 2nd West Yorkshire Regiment attacked the ridge and captured four hundred sixty Italian prisoners. At 1800 hours the 3/12th Frontier Force Regiment captured Italian positions on White Rock Ridge covering demolitions on the road. Asmara was handed over on April 1st and the 10th Brigade entered the town while the 9th Brigade was ordered to move to Ad Teclesan the same day. The Battalion then moved to Asmara on April 2nd. On the night of April 3rd/4th, the 9th Brigade was ordered to take over station duties at Asmara from the 10th Indian Brigade.

    On the evening of April 23rd, ‘A’ Company returned to the Battalion from occupation duties at Wahni and the Battalion was ordered to leave Asmara at 0700 hours on April 24th. The 3rd Battalion was to come under the command of the 29th Indian Infantry Brigade and take over the line of communications between Asmara and the Amba Alagi battle area.
     
    davidbfpo and Rothy like this.

Share This Page