How long before they're all photographed?

Discussion in 'War Grave Photographs' started by von Poop, Jul 23, 2008.

  1. von Poop

    von Poop Adaministrator Admin

    The thought occurs...
    Hopefully there'll come a day when every known WW2 (and WW1 & other conflicts) grave and memorial is to be found somewhere on the web.
    It's one of the most positive things I can see happening, can't believe the speed of collection and obscurity of some of the locations, and just wondered how far you people collecting photographs think we are from cheerfully closing this section as no longer needed?

    Sometimes the interweb really impresses me.

    RAAF_MEMORIAL
    Veteran_looking_for_his_mates_Grave
    Tunisia_Grave
    etc.

    Cheers,
    Adam.
     
  2. dbf

    dbf Moderatrix MOD

    Hi VP,

    Think this all depends on how good we all are at sharing too. I have placed all those I received up on photobucket and labelled them with cwgc details and tagged them...

    Personally I am quite happy to pay for a photo IF I absolutely have to but then we are getting into the areas of copyright again if use is for anything other than personal records. I also think it is good manners to ask first before using and to give credit where it is due. If those little nicities are followed then why wouldn't we all place our collections up on the net?

    I would've loved this to be the responsibility of those who actually care for the graves. It seems strange to me that the headstones, memorials and cemeteries are looked after with such care, when really in proportion so few actually get to see them... old argument and finances again I know. Still, wouldn't it be great to go into the cwgc site and enter a virtual cemetery?

    I have been fortunate to have had so much help in such a quick period of time, but I haven't started with my 1BN IGs yet and, dealing with their commemorative sites, well ....

    Wonder how anyone else has managed with the likes of Norway, Italy and N. Africa en masse ...

    I feel a trip to the fjords coming along ...
    d
     
  3. spidge

    spidge RAAF RESEARCHER

    For me it could be years. I still have just under 8,000 WW2 lads to go and have 180/316 WW1 lads. This is now one year since I commenced the RAAF/RAF and the network is increasing. The WW1 lads I commenced in February this year.

    My requirements initially were 1066 cemeteries which increased to 1097 when I found 202 more Aussies that died in the RAF. The WW1 burials added another 161 cemeteries to the list for just 316 deaths.

    So, 1258 cemeteries in 65 countries. Most of the cemeteries have one, two or three burials as the crews in most cases were a mixture of Commonwealth flyers.
     
  4. von Poop

    von Poop Adaministrator Admin

    Still amazing to me that we're now talking 'years' intead of 'never', or 'not possible'.
    During the few I did it struck me & the other half that 'pre-internet' just those bomb-disposal graves would have been a lifetime's endeavour for one person, and there'd be nowhere to share them easily anyway. Now these things can be chipped away at by small packets of volunteers.
    I'm sure there's a fair bit of repetition going on, but the general archive is definitely getting larger at a rate of knots.

    Rather good.
     
  5. dbf

    dbf Moderatrix MOD

    Still amazing to me that we're now talking 'years' intead of 'never', or 'not possible'.
    During the few I did it struck me & the other half that 'pre-internet' just those bomb-disposal graves would have been a lifetime's endeavour for one person, and there'd be nowhere to share them easily anyway. Now these things can be chipped away at by small packets of volunteers.
    I'm sure there's a fair bit of repetition going on, but the general archive is definitely getting larger at a rate of knots.

    Rather good.


    Agree with you VP about the problems of where to place them pre-internet. No good in someone's folder ... and the idea of getting help, well just where would I have started without this Forum for instance?

    Not only are there lots of great researchers on this site who are a credit to their respective spheres of interest, but plenty of others willing to give up time to photograph headstones etc.

    I'd like to thank again all those who have helped me so far and also to acknowledge another piece of amazing work by another Forum member at http://www.irishwarmemorials.ie/

    I would also like to encourage forum members and non-forum members alike, to read our requests on this war graves subforum and check to see if they can help. For those who fear a deluge of requests, please bear in mind that we can be contacted by PM too.

    Most of us who are looking for help are not in any rush and would very much appreciate it, if a detour on another planned journey could help us out. Have to bear in mind costs of travel as well as our carbon footprint these days!

    Regards,
    Diane

    :poppy:
     
  6. AndyBaldEagle

    AndyBaldEagle Very Senior Member

    The thing is there are lots of us all doing this. I was looking up the locations of all the UK cemeteries/churchyards I need to obtain pics from and found a site for Friends of a particular cemetery. Emailed them in the evening and told them what I was about, and the following afternoon received two photographs of headstones, one was mine, one was very post war (1977) asking if that was what I was after. What service!
    I have not bothered to count up how many cemeteries/churchyards I have, defintiely not as many as Spidge.
    I must admit I would prefer not to pay for a pic, but do realise that some are far beyond my reach.


    Regards to all

    Andy
    We will all get there in the end, and then what are we going to do?
     
  7. von Poop

    von Poop Adaministrator Admin

    We will all get there in the end, and then what are we going to do?
    I'd been thinking that.
    Must be similar projects a forum can help with, gathering little bits to make a more significant whole...

    Sure they'll come along.
     
  8. GPRegt

    GPRegt Senior Member

    I think I've mentioned elsewhere on the Forum some of the research I've done into the Old Nortonians (of King's Norton Boys' School where I work) who died during both World Wars. I've decided to photograph the Birmingham graves, including private burials and non-KNBS. The School ones I will be putting on our website. I guess I'll store the others. I'll put up a list when I've finished.

    Steve W.
     
  9. Rich Payne

    Rich Payne Rivet Counter Patron 1940 Obsessive

    Going on from what Diane says, it would indeed seem appropriate if the CWGC themselves made photographs available. They have gardeners on-site regularly and presumably supervisors who could wield a camera ?

    I have never had contact with the CWGC but I have the impression that they are sticking with their original remit of memorials for the next of kin. They do not really seem to have realised that erm 'Wargraves Tourists' (if that's the correct term) exist - perhaps there actually aren't very many and they are all on this forum where WW2 is concerned ?

    I feel that they could do much more in terms of making the whereabouts of graves known. As an organisation that works so efficiently in terms of maintenance they must surely have the records easily available for all locations within a given area ?

    The internet has made much of this research possible but three cheers as well for the inventor of the digital camera ! I photographed a few graves for others whilst I was still analogue but the cost and agravation would make it unrealistic for more than the odd grave for a family member or somesuch.
     
  10. arneken

    arneken Member

    Since I bacame active on international forums I've been contacted several times about taking a picture here and there. I think its all just for the greater good and what after every grave is photographed? I think we'll have some more years work cause In Flanders this year alone 8 german soldiers were recovered and several British/commenwealth soldiers were given a new/known restingplace.
     
  11. dbf

    dbf Moderatrix MOD

    Going on from what Diane says, it would indeed seem appropriate if the CWGC themselves made photographs available. They have gardeners on-site regularly and presumably supervisors who could wield a camera ?

    I have never had contact with the CWGC but I have the impression that they are sticking with their original remit of memorials for the next of kin. They do not really seem to have realised that erm 'Wargraves Tourists' (if that's the correct term) exist - perhaps there actually aren't very many and they are all on this forum where WW2 is concerned ?

    I feel that they could do much more in terms of making the whereabouts of graves known. As an organisation that works so efficiently in terms of maintenance they must surely have the records easily available for all locations within a given area ?

    The internet has made much of this research possible but three cheers as well for the inventor of the digital camera ! I photographed a few graves for others whilst I was still analogue but the cost and agravation would make it unrealistic for more than the odd grave for a family member or somesuch.

    Hi Rich,
    It had also occured to me about the caretakers...they only need to do it once and then archive them...even with the largest cemeteries, you have to start somewhere.

    As for the graves being primarily for the NOK, we have a connection with 2 WWI soldiers whose entire branch of the family is now defunct. Repeat that and add a splash of those who have no idea of family members who served, and as time passes, many of the fallen will have no 'personal connection' to a family any more... I don't suppose this has been taken into account at all, and it should. WW1 provides a very good example of this already. Those who tour battlefields and visit war cemeteries, and who post photos for those who can't, are keeping the knowledge fresh, and this part of our collective education should not be overlooked.

    The site at http://www.twgpp.org/index.php charges for photographs that volunteers have taken. While there is no other official means to get one, this is as good as it gets for the Brits. I am ambivilent about the site and I have even sent in photo for them. I can understand the need for funds for running costs; they do not get anything from cwgc, but on the other hand they should, and the charter should be amended to bring it up into the 21st century...

    The 'general view' photos placed up on cwgc could do with refreshing and some of the location info - if there is any at all - is unhelpful to say the least. Cemetery names in some cases bear no relation to what is now used. I, with some local knowledge still had to resort to googling to confirm whereabouts of some of Spidge's in NI, how dumb is that?

    Hear, hear as to the digital camera. My cupboards are full of negs. copies, and albums, so much easier to store and to share now.

    Regards,
    Diane
     
  12. spidge

    spidge RAAF RESEARCHER

    =dbf;143757]Hi Rich,
    I, with some local knowledge still had to resort to googling to confirm whereabouts of some of Spidge's in NI, how dumb is that?
    Hi Diane,

    Did you get my message about Lisburn?

    Hear, hear as to the digital camera. My cupboards are full of negs. copies, and albums, so much easier to store and to share now.
    Hooray for the digital camera.

    When I went to the Northern Territory a few months ago, I had 400 RAAF lads to photograph at Adelaide River Cemetery.

    I took over 400 photos in 3 1/2 hours on the same memory card and one battery.

    Came home, downloaded them yet still to catalogue more than half of them.

    Total cost - Zip!
     
  13. dbf

    dbf Moderatrix MOD

    Hi Geoff,
    Message about looking for address?:) Yes, thanks.

    Not to worry though, I will go down to the one I am thinking of and have a wander around...next couple of weeks a little up in the air, but will get there. If it's the wrong one I'll try again.

    Diane

    Edit: In reply to post below, Geoff I have sent you a PM.
     
  14. spidge

    spidge RAAF RESEARCHER

    Hi Geoff,
    Message about looking for address?:) Yes, thanks.

    Not to worry though, I will go down to the one I am thinking of and have a wander around...next couple of weeks a little up in the air, but will get there. If it's the wrong one I'll try again.

    Diane

    I meant the copy of the email I received and forwarded to you from the council at Lisburn with the actual address of the cemetery.

    Cheers

    Geoff
     
  15. spidge

    spidge RAAF RESEARCHER

    Hi Geoff,
    Message about looking for address?:) Yes, thanks.

    Not to worry though, I will go down to the one I am thinking of and have a wander around...next couple of weeks a little up in the air, but will get there. If it's the wrong one I'll try again.

    Diane

    I meant the copy of the email I received and forwarded to you from the council at Lisburn with the actual address of the cemetery.

    Cheers

    Geoff
     
  16. Rich Payne

    Rich Payne Rivet Counter Patron 1940 Obsessive

    Hello Diane, I must admit that I didn't know about the war graves photographic project. I almost feel cheated that they've been getting there before me ! I actually quite like the personal feel of 'knowing' who I'm photographing for and their 'donation' of £3 is quite expensive if the actual work is done by volunteers. That said, for a family geneaologist needing just one picture, it is ideal.

    Where the system is inadequate is when the interest is more academic and encompasses complete units.

    I have no personal axe to grind with CWGC. In fact it amazes me that they're still funded. It's just, as you point out rather a feeling that they're not moving with the times and that in some way they need to be doing all they can to ensure that the lesser known graves are visited.

    I was very aware from the notices on old graves in the French civil cemeteries that they are keen on removing old burials where the concession has expired (generally 100 years there I think and that seems to be their definition of perpetuity). Has the 100 year question been answered on the WW1 graves ? If not, it won't be long before we'll be needing to show that these sites have been visited.

    I don't think that there is a problem in Belgium although civil concessions are only fifty years as the shopkeepers of Ieper make too much money selling chocolates to British schoolchildren !

    Rich
     
  17. burlington

    burlington Member

    The Project 'The War Graves Photographic Project' is working towards this goal. I quote from their website, War Grave and Memorial Photographs supplied by The War Graves Photographic Project:

    <quote>
    he aim of The War Graves Photographic Project is to photograph every war grave, individual memorial, MoD grave, and family memorial of serving military personnel from WWI to the present day and make these available within a searchable database. Now working as a joint venture with the Commonwealth War Graves Commission, this will enable families, scholars and researchers to obtain, via the CWGC or TWGPP websites, a copy of the photograph of a grave or memorial which for many is impossible to visit due to the location.</quote>


    Over 1 million are already available with quite a few still to go.
     
  18. englandphil

    englandphil Very Senior Member

    I am happy to say that with the arrival over the weekend of the photographs of the 21 South Lancs Headstones buried in Diego Suarez, Madagascar I have now obtained over 90% of all of the South Lancs Casualties, including a list of over 550 who served the battalions at some point during their army service.

    P :)
     
    Pieter F likes this.
  19. Pieter F

    Pieter F Very Senior Member

    I am happy to say that with the arrival over the weekend of the photographs of the 21 South Lancs Headstones buried in Diego Suarez, Madagascar I have now obtained over 90% of all of the South Lancs Casualties, including a list of over 550 who served the battalions at some point during their army service.

    P :)

    A fanstastic effort Phil!
     
  20. cretophile

    cretophile Junior Member

    I am relatively new to this site but have an involvement with others in related fields. I have been looking for references here to The War Graves Photographic Project (War Grave and Memorial Photographs supplied by The War Graves Photographic Project) but not come across any so far.
    I am sure the site will be of interest to many given some of the postings I have seen here. TWGPP started off under another name and with the intention of photographing the headstone or memorial of every British serviceman or woman killed in action, or dying from injuries received in action since the start of WW1- wherever those headstones or memorials may be.
    It has subsequently grown like Topsy and now covers a wider field. There has been cooperation with C.W.G.C. from the very beginning, they kindly supplying information as to 'target' graves. Now there is a formal association with the C.W.G.C.
    The TWGPP is composed entirely of volunteers from all over the world and, last time I looked they had over 1.5 million images collected and recorded to date. These are searchable. Donations are sought for electronic or hard copies of images to cover the considerable costs of operating the website etc but collecting and recording is done freely by volunteers. Some far flung members of this (WW2Talk) site may be interested in contributing, details of how to assist are on the TWGPP site. Others may be interested in the contents. Because of past abuse of the information and images, steps have had to be taken to protect copyright but I hope that all will find it a useful, informative and valuable resource even though it's being was intended initially as a resource for the families of the dead and a lasting memorial to them.
    The site is not concerned with town and village memorials as such, but centered upon the individuals concerned.
    Personally, I think it is a prime example of the internet being put to good use.
    Sadly it looks like being an ongoing project for all the wrong reasons. My apologies if I repeat information available elsewhere on this site.
    Tim
     

Share This Page